“Just talk to your users” is advice everyone gives and almost nobody does well.
Here’s the problem: there isn’t one kind of interview. There are structured interviews, where every participant gets the same questions in the same order — useful for comparison, but blind to context. There are semi-structured interviews, where a guide provides direction but the conversation follows the participant’s lead. There are unstructured interviews, closer to a conversation than a questionnaire, where the researcher follows threads that weren’t anticipated.
And then there’s contextual inquiry — arguably the most powerful method in the HCI toolkit. You don’t ask people what they do. You watch them do it, in their environment, in the moment, and you ask questions while the experience is still fresh. The insight isn’t in what they say. It’s in the gap between what they say and what they do.
Each method surfaces different signal. Structured interviews give you breadth. Contextual inquiry gives you truth. There’s a science to knowing which to use, when, and how to synthesise what comes back — which is the science behind how interview agents work and writing good questions.
That science takes years to develop. Now it’s yours.